
Millennials all think they have the best Batman cartoon, just because it has Mark Hamill as the Joker, Mister Freeze’s tragic backstory, top-tier character designs and atmosphere, dramatic storytelling far beyond the average children’s program, Condiment King, and… well, you know what, they’re absolutely right. As much as I’d love to stick it to those crusty old ’90s kids, Batman: The Animated Series is without a doubt the most iconic cartoon adaptation of the caped crusader, and there’s really no way I can pretend otherwise. On the other hand, there are two other animated series from my own childhood that I believe are worthy of at least a little more appreciation than they’ve received: the first is The Batman, which ran from 2004-2008, and the second is Batman: The Brave and the Bold, airing between 2008 and 2011.
Both of these are series that I only caught glimpses of as a kid (oddly enough, I remember watching Batman Beyond more frequently than either of them). But after revisiting each show in recent years, I’ve found them to have a surprising amount of entertainment value. The Batman (2004) is clearly attempting to follow in the footsteps of its 1990s predecessor, showcasing a gritty, red-skied Gotham with a colorful cavalcade of callous crooks for the chiropteran combatant to clobber. In contrast, Brave and the Bold is a comedy-oriented action romp that highlights characters from DC’s expanded universe, where Batman regularly teams up with the likes of Aquaman, the Green Lanterns, and even the obscure post-apocalyptic hero Kamandi. In this article, I thought it would be fun to compare the two underrecognized cartoons side-by-side, measuring their worth in various categories to determine which show is superior.

Protagonist Portrayal
One of the most notable differences between the two series is how they depict their titular hero. The Batman shows the viewers a younger Bruce Wayne struggling to adapt to his dual identity. We see him face the temptation to reveal his secret to his best friend, question if his vigilantism is doing more harm than good, and even try to figure out his romantic life. This show also has a unique dynamic between Bruce and Alfred. Most Pennyworth portrayals tend to paint him as firmly supportive of “master Wayne”, sometimes to the point where he comes across as annoyingly submissive. However, this version of Alfred is highly critical of Bruce’s lifestyle. In fact, he would love nothing more than for the boy he raised to quit this dangerous and lonesome crusade altogether, and he’s not shy about saying so. All in all, this show does a lot to emphasize Batman’s “human” issues, which is not something you tend to see with adaptations aimed at a younger audience.

In stark contrast, Batman: The Brave and the Bold barely even acknowledges that Bruce Wayne exists. We see the protagonist in costume practically the whole time he’s on screen. This show depicts an experienced Batman who confidently bears his responsibility as the protector of not only Gotham, but the entire world, if not the whole universe. Even when dealing with other respected heroes, he naturally assumes a leadership position, with most of his associates deferring to his sound judgment and moral clarity without question (except Guy Gardner of course). In some cases, Batman’s confidence starts to border on arrogance, but he always proves he has the skills and knowledge to back up his ego.
Choosing a favorite between these portrayals of Batman wasn’t easy, because I honestly think they both work. But all things considered, I’d say Brave and the Bold better encapsulates the true essence of the character. The dual identity aspect that The Batman accentuates is perfectly fine, but not exactly unique in superhero stories. If anything, I’d say their depiction of Bruce is more reminiscent of Peter Parker in some ways. Brave and the Bold understands that being the guy who always knows what to do and faces any threat with unflinching determination is Batman’s signature quality.
Score: The Batman 0-Brave and the Bold 1
Rogues’ Gallery
A superhero show would be nothing without a cast of recurring villains to prove the failures of its fictional penal system, and both shows deliver on this, albeit with very different character selections. The Batman takes a more conventional approach (in a sense), with primarily Gotham-based criminals. It most prominently features popular characters like Joker, Penguin, Riddler, Catwoman, and Mister Freeze, but also leaves room for some obscure villains, my personal favorite being the Ventriloquist (who’s flawlessly voiced by Dan Castellaneta). However, while most of this show’s antagonists have name recognition, the writers and artists take a lot of creative liberties with their presentation. Many of the rogues are heavily redesigned from their comic counterparts, which usually works well, but with one or two disastrous exceptions. Several villains also have notably altered personalities and backstories, with Clayface being the prime example. In this version of the story, he’s a detective and close friend to Bruce named Ethan Bennet, who is transformed by the Joker using an experimental mutagen (though a second Clayface is later introduced with the same name and background as the character from the comics). Ethan is presented as more of a troubled antihero than a traditional villain, driven by a desire to exact vengeance on Joker and frustrated by his difficulties reentering society. Altogether, I’m quite fond of the rogues’ gallery in this series. I appreciate the effort to reimagine decades-old characters so they can remain fresh and interesting, and some of the villains in The Batman are the best I’ve seen in animated form since the ’90s cartoon (and then there’s the Riddler).




Batman: The Brave and the Bold takes a very different approach to its bad guy lineup, shifting the spotlight away from Gotham onto other DC antagonists, including Gorilla Grodd, Gentleman Ghost, and even Darkseid. Also unlike The Batman, this show makes an effort to preserve its villains’ iconicity, keeping their designs and personas fairly accurate to the comics. But one thing Brave and the Bold has in common with its predecessor is a fondness for occasionally exposing its audience to a D-lister they’ve probably never heard of, such as the Weeper and Animal-Vegetable-Mineral Man. This show also introduces one completely original villain called Music Meister, and he’s criminally underrated if you ask me (just watch episode 125 if you don’t believe me).

This was another tough call, but in the end, I had to give the point to The Batman. First of all, it clearly has a greater commitment to actual Batman villains, whereas Brave and the Bold barely gives any notice to most of the Gotham gangsters. In addition, while I can respect the desire to keep the villains similar to their comic book iterations, I have to give The Batman props for their more innovative approach. And finally, The Batman clearly has the superior Joker, and it’s frankly not even close.

Score: The Batman 1-Brave and the Bold 1
Action Sequences
Any Batman series worth its salt has to include some good batbeatdowns, whether they’re going for thrilling martial arts choreography or campy onomatopoeia-filled punch ’em ups. Unfortunately, Batman: Brave and the Bold is somewhat lacking in this area. Ironically, its devotion to the comic book aesthetic hurts its fight scenes, as they often boil down to dramatic still frames with minimal animation connecting them. And even the action that is animated tends to be pretty basic: Batman socks this guy, throws a batarang at that guy, and so on. They do throw in some creative bits of animation here and there, like one scene with the Atom that I consider a highlight of season 1, but moments like these tend to be frustratingly short-lived and sparse.


The Batman is the clear winner in terms of the action. While its animation is far from perfect, its directors were clearly trying to capture the vibe of a martial arts movie, which in my opinion suits Batman perfectly. Every fight scene is full of cinematic choreography: rapid exchanges of blows, characters flipping and tumbling all over, incorporating the environment into the action, creative camerawork, and so forth. This show is also fond of fights three-way fights, where things really get good. For example, here’s a little excerpt from a fight between Batman, Catwoman, and Rag Doll inside a clocktower (and you’ve got to give this show props for making a ridiculous character like Rag Doll actually seem cool).


Score: The Batman 2-Brave and the Bold 1
Humor
As one would typically expect, a cartoon is supposed to include a healthy dose of comedy, whether crude slapstick, witty dialogue, or visual gags. Honestly, this one is really no contest. The Batman has its funny moments, usually stemming from Bruce and Alfred’s smug sassiness or Kevin Michael Richardson’s irreverent line deliveries as the Joker, but when it comes down to it, it just isn’t really a comedy show. Most of the time, the writers are clearly trying to convey a more dramatic tone, with just a touch of comic relief to break the tension.
In contrast, Brave and the Bold is dedicated to showing that Batman can be a hilarious character when given the right scenarios to play with. This is a Batman who will face the most ludicrous of situations—Gorilla Grodd plotting to turn all humans into apes, the Music Meister forcing heroes to sing and dance for him, or Red Tornado’s robot son realizing he’s not a real boy—and treat them with utmost seriousness. In addition, the writers make a point to pair him with boisterous characters like Booster Gold and Plastic Man who can bounce off his no-nonsense demeanor and dry wit.

I’m not going to explain the intricacies of time travel to a man without a library card!
Not only are the jokes in Brave and the Bold funny, but they’re shockingly well-researched and clearly come from a place of genuine love for DC comics. For example, there’s an episode featuring Superman that frequently references the silly cover art of his golden age publications, with quotes that are taken directly from their speech bubbles.


Score: The Batman 2-Brave and the Bold 2
Adam West Cameos
As the most iconic actor to ever play the bespandexed sleuth on TV, it’s no surprise that both Batman cartoons of the 2000s included a special guest appearance from the late Adam West. The Batman has him playing the mayor of Gotham, who appears in several episodes and has run-ins with the Joker, Poison Ivy, and Maximillian Zeus. While it is funny that West plays a town mayor in this show, given that it’s the same profession as his namesake character in Family Guy, and he of course performs his lines more than adequately, he’s not particularly interesting. A different actor could have easily been cast for this character, and it wouldn’t have really changed much about him.
On the other hand, Batman: The Brave and the Bold knows exactly what role Adam West was made for (other than Batman himself). He makes a unique appearance in one of the best episodes in the entire series: 211 Chill of the Night! This episode is rare in that it focuses on Bruce Wayne more than Batman, following his efforts to track down his parents’ murderer. At one point, Bruce is sent to the past by the Phantom Stranger to help him find clues, where he gets to reunite with his father Thomas Wayne, who is naturally voiced by West. To add to the homage, Bruce’s mother is played by Julie Newmar, who portrayed Catwoman in the same series that West starred in (the episode also features Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill of the ’90s animated series). There’s one more episode of Brave and the Bold with Adam West, where he lends his voice to a prototype robot created by Batman to help him fight crime. It’s cute, but nowhere near as noteworthy. In any case, Brave and the Bold obviously takes the prize when it comes to properly utilizing the OG Batman.

Score: The Batman 2-Brave and the Bold 3
Final Thoughts
So, with the final score coming in at 2 points for The Batman and 3 for Batman: The Brave and the Bold, it would seem that the latter is the ultimate victor in this little contest. Of course, the scoring system is more than a little arbitrary, so I wouldn’t expect you to take this as a serious review of either series. However, if I had to say which show I genuinely thought was better, it would probably still be Brave and the Bold. While I do have a certain fondness for The Batman’s unique take on familiar characters (despite butchering the Riddler), and I think its animation is a little nicer to look at, its successor does such a better job of paying homage to the comics and has significantly better writing. Plus, Diedrich Bader’s performance is just perfect for showing off Batman’s humorous side (and I can’t be the only one who thinks so, given that he reprised his role in the recent Harley Quinn series). All in all, The Batman is a fine Saturday morning cartoon, and I would recommend checking it out (at least the first three seasons), but Brave in the Bold truly embodies what makes superhero cartoons so much fun, and I think any batfan would enjoy watching it from beginning to end.
