The Friendly Confederate Ghost: DC’s Most Questionable Superhero

The time has finally come for my first “controversial” article, and since it’s October, I thought I’d add a little spooky flair as well. So, we’re going to take a deepish dive into one of DC’s many obscure and antiquated characters: the fictionalized ghost of real-life historical figure General James Ewell Brown “J.E.B.” Stuart. I’ll be discussing the origins, adaptations, and my overall impression of the seceding spirit.

DC comics has a long history of heroes who fight evil from beyond the grave, from Deadman to the original Spectre. Therefore, it may not come as a surprise that one of their recurring characters for several decades was the disembodied soul of a Civil War veteran… but apparently, they thought it would be more interesting if that soldier had fought for the losing team. And so began the Haunted Tank, a series beginning in 1961 (exactly 100 years after the start of the Civil War) that follows the exploits of a tank driver in World War II as he’s given advice and assistance from General Stuart of the Confederate States of America. And if that premise sounds iffy to you, just keep reading, because I promise it gets so much worse.

Silver Age Origins

The original Haunted Tank was featured in G.I. Combat, a publication known for its patriotic (bordering on nationalistic) military-themed comics, often set in the second World War. It began as a loose anthology, but as soon as Haunted Tank debuted in issue #87, it pretty much became the headliner for almost every issue thereafter, continuing until the final chapter in 1987. The popularity of this series may have been due to the unique inclusion of its key supernatural element. While other stories from G.I. Combat were “realistic” adventures (by the standards of war comics anyway), Haunted Tank intrigued its readers with its ghostly supporting protagonist.

The hero of this story is Sergeant Jeb Stuart, the descendant and namesake of General J.E.B. Stuart. He grew up idolizing his ancestor and hoped to be just like him (as in a great soldier, not the… other stuff). As soon as Jeb comes of age, he enlists with his friends Rick, Slim, and Arch, and the four of them are assigned an M3 Stuart tank (which of course was named after J.E.B.). Throughout their daring adventures, Sergeant Stuart often communes with the ghost of General Stuart (whom nobody else can see or hear), looking to him for guidance in these trying times. Bound by the vaguely defined ghost rules, the General can’t give his descendant too much help, only offering cryptic warnings about upcoming dangers and raising his morale with his war stories (and occasionally having duels with other famous ghosts like Attila the Hun).

I’ll admit that I found the inclusion of a historical figure as a “guardian angel” an intriguing hook for a war story, so I can see why this would’ve sold well back when Nazi-punching comics were all the rage. And some of the bizarre lore they introduce later on is pretty funny, like how J.E.B.’s boss is apparently Alexander the Great, and he’s the one who assigns him to watch over Sergeant Jeb in the first place. However, I still don’t really understand why the creators felt the need to pick a Confederate hero when they had plenty of other patriotic options, such as General William Sherman of the Union, who also has a tank named after him (and they literally end up in an M4 Sherman after their original tank gets destroyed).

The main thing I noticed while skimming through decades of Haunted Tank is that despite how prominently J.E.B. is featured, I couldn’t find even a single reference in any issue I read to the thing the Civil War was about and the reason the Confederates are viewed as the bad guys in any civilized part of this country. While General Stuart’s many positive qualities are highlighted throughout the series—his bravery in the face of overwhelming odds, his keen tactical prowess, his willingness to fight alongside “Yanks”—we never get to hear his opinions on certain sociopolitical issues, almost to the point where it feels like such topics are being intentionally avoided. The writers seem to have a strangely neutral take on the Civil War, with neither side being definitively right or wrong. It comes across as irresponsibly tone-deaf, to put it mildly (and shamefully pandering to white supremacist ideology, to put it much more harshly). And sure, you could argue that there were “good men” fighting on both sides, and valiant acts were not inherently limited to the Union soldiers, and blah blah blah… but one side owned human beings as property, so it really shouldn’t be all that controversial to show some favoritism.

Funny enough, I think the main protagonist (the Jeb who still has meat on his bones) actually annoyed me more than his namesake. While Sergeant Jeb is meant to come across as a true-blue American hero fighting for a noble cause, the way he blindly idolizes General Stuart with no concern for the values he fought for is pretty creepy. He’s even willing to fly a Confederate flag from his tank with no hesitation whatsoever just to earn his ancestor’s approval (and he ends up adding a Black soldier to his company in later issues, if you needed that to sound even worse).

All in all, I would say I am very much not a fan of this classic series. While most of its stories are alright for Silver Age war comics, the inexplicable and unnecessary adoration of its Confederate supporting protagonist raises way too many red flags (both literal and figurative). It feels like the writers of Haunted Tank were grossly misunderstanding the history they were so intent on celebrating, and even in the ’60s, that seems inexcusable. And frankly, I just can’t help but wonder how a Black parent would’ve felt when they flipped through some of their kid’s comic book collection and found out they were reading this, which is a scenario that I don’t think ever crossed the minds of the publishers back then.

Later Adaptations

While you might wish otherwise after reading the previous section, Haunted Tank doesn’t end after its original run in G.I. Comics. Like most of DC’s franchises, it was milked for all it’s worth in sequels, crossovers, and reboots. General J.E.B. Stuart has met with Etrigan, Hawk & Dove, and Anarky (if you don’t know who any of those characters are, I don’t blame you). The Haunted Tank has also appeared in a one-off reboot of G.I. Comics in 2010 and has even been referenced in two children’s animated series: Batman: The Brave and the Bold and Teen Titans Go! (both omitted the tank’s iconic Confederate flag for obvious reasons). But Ghost J.E.B.’s most notable modern incarnation is perhaps the short-lived sequel in 2009 published by Vertigo.

For those who are unfamiliar with Vertigo, it’s basically where all of DC’s most excessively edgy comics come from. It includes works such as Preacher, Garth Ennis’ spiritual predecessor to The Boys, and an adaptation of Django Unchained. It was an interesting choice to hand off a series like Haunted Tank to Vertigo, since the original comics don’t really fit its image. But what we ended up with is really… well, the truth is I’m not entirely sure how best to describe it.

This 5-part series is set in the Iraq War, already differentiating itself from the original run by using an ongoing conflict instead of a historical one (as well as a war where the nobility of its cause was a lot less apparent). The new Haunted Tank follows Sergeant Jamal Stuart, who is on a mission to go… somewhere and do… something… yeah, I wasn’t really paying much attention to that part of the story. The important thing is that J.E.B. Stuart once again comes up from He- I mean down from Heaven to help his bloodline. But the twist (which you may have guessed from his name) is that this protagonist has a certain complexion that immediately drives a wedge between him and General Stuart.

The sequel changes quite a lot from the classic series, both in terms of lore and themes. For instance, instead of being assigned as the guardian of Sergeant Stuart’s tank by the ghost of Alexander the Great, J.E.B. was cursed by a vodou shaman as revenge for raping a slave woman; I think that gives a pretty good impression of the differences in tone between the two series. Another difference is that the ghost rules have apparently gotten a lot more relaxed since WWII. Rather than just giving vague advice solely to his descendant, General Stuart can now be seen by the entire crew and even participate in combat, using his spectral saber to slice up enemy tanks and intercept their shells (it’s honestly pretty awesome). The way J.E.B.’s ghost is utilized in this story actually reminds me somewhat of stands in JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure, the main difference being that Star Platinum wasn’t constantly calling Jotaro a “chink”.

And this brings me to the main theme of the series: the messy relationship between Jamal and his ancestral spirit. In stark contrast to the original Haunted Tank and its bootlicking hero, the new Sergeant Stuart expresses unapologetic hostility toward J.E.B., after immediately confronting him about his views on slavery and receiving the exact answer he was expecting. Throughout all five issues, we see Jamal bickering nonstop with General Stuart and trying in vain to make him get with the times. J.E.B., on the other hand, expresses a genuine desire to help Jamal in any way he can, while refusing to change any of his ignorant views. It’s actually a somewhat compelling dynamic, but it gets repetitive after a while and is ultimately unsatisfying.

My overall impression of Haunted Tank (2009) is that it is largely an improvement over the first series, mainly because the writers don’t shy away from the obvious elephant in the room. It also has some cool artwork and manages to be pretty funny at times. However, I still wouldn’t say it’s great. Like many comics of this era, it feels like it’s desperate to be taken seriously by an adult audience, relying on gratuitous crass dialogue and easy shock value to accomplish such a goal. For example, there’s one scene where Jamal and his men gun down an incoming truck that they assume is full of enemy soldiers, only to find that it was mainly inhabited by now-slaughtered civilians; while meant to come across as emotionally heavy, it just feels painfully cliche. In particular, I find Jamal’s crew to be a constant annoyance, each being a one-dimensional stereotype that adds nothing to the core dynamic. There’s the nerdy Asian guy, the hotblooded Latino, and the hillbilly with a Confederate flag tattoo (who also puts the flag on Jamal’s tank as a very unnecessary “homage” to the original story). For the most part, this series felt like a cheap knockoff of The Boondocks, copying its subject matter and style of humor but comparatively lacking in clever satire and meaningful commentary. In other words, it’s not terrible, but also not good enough to justify a character revival that I’m fairly certain nobody was asking for.

Final Thoughts

After reading WAY too many issues of Haunted Tank, my overall conclusion is that J.E.B. Stuart is just as problematic of a “hero” as I anticipated. While some aspects of his portrayal in both the older and newer works did surprise me, and I admittedly found him interesting at times, at the end of the day, he really is just a Confederate ghost in a shell, and there’s not all that much you can do with that.

It’s clear that the writers of the original comics weren’t thinking at all about how insensitive a protagonist like General Stuart would come across to Black readers (I don’t think most mainstream American media back then was really trying to appeal to that demographic), and the naively idealistic nature of his presentation reminds me a lot of other glorified and oversimplified figures such as Christopher Columbus. And no matter how progressively DC tries to approach this character in modern depictions, it’s very hard for today’s readers to find much appeal in him (unless there are a lot more comics fans in the Southern Baptist Church than I realize). Maybe they could try giving J.E.B. a genuine “redemption arc” at some point, where he finally realizes that slavery is bad and admits he fought for the wrong side, but I think even that would just come across as shallow and hokey. So, it seems that General Stuart’s ghost is just one of those outdated relics of comics history, doomed to be absent from modern media outside of purely nostalgic or satirical appearances. And if you ask me, that’s for the best.

I still can’t believe that a TV show for kids is how I found out this character existed…